4/22/1928, SP28-CCT28, Polo Grounds
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10 11 12
1928 Spiders           0  0  3  0  0  0  0  0  0  0  2  1
1928 Crimson Tide      0  0  1  0  0  0  2  0  0  0  2  1
 
                      13 14 15     R  H  E   LOB DP
1928 Spiders           0  0  0     6 13  0    10  0
1928 Crimson Tide      0  0  1     7 19  2    22  0
 
Spiders              AB  R  H BI   AVG    Crimson Tide         AB  R  H BI   AVG
Briggs            lf  7  2  3  1  .277    Cobb              rf  5  0  0  0  .308
Blue              1b  4  1  1  1  .241     Fernandez        ph  1  0  0  0  .250
Hodapp            3b  4  1  1  1  .250     Holloway         p   1  0  0  0  .000
 Dressen          3b  2  0  1  1  .125    Williams,K        lf  6  2  3  0  .276
Hafey             cf  7  1  1  2  .295     Livingston       ph  2  0  1  1  .267
Thomas, C         rf  7  0  1  0  .373    Creacy            3b  7  2  3  0  .229
Russell, JH       2b  5  0  3  0  .203    Frisch            2b  6  0  2  0  .388
 Nehf             p   0  0  0  0  .000    Charleston        cf  5  0  0  1  .290
Hargreaves        c   7  1  0  0  .146    Hauser            1b  5  1  2  3  .286
Bancroft          ss  6  0  0  0  .089     Washington, J    ph  3  1  2  1  .412
Powell            p   2  0  0  0  .333    Lundy             ss  5  0  0  0  .362
 Walker           ph  1  0  1  0  .429    Spearman          c   6  0  3  0  .308
 Vangilder        p   0  0  0  0  .000    Tyler, SA         p   4  0  0  0  .091
 Dickey           ph  1  0  0  0  .000     Taitt            ph  1  0  0  0  .143
 Ehmke            p   0  0  0  0  .000     Johnson          p   0  0  0  0  .000
 Page             p   0  0  0  0  .000     Reynolds         ph  3  1  3  1  .381
 Littlejohn       p   0  0  0  0  .000                         60  7 19  7
 Gooch            ph  1  0  1  0  .538
 Strelecki        p   0  0  0  0  .000
 Settlemire       p   0  0  0  0  .000
 Connally         p   1  0  0  0  .000
 Gillis           2b  0  0  0  0  .000
                     55  6 13  6
 
Spiders                          INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Powell                           7.0 10  3  3  5  8 140  85  3.28
Vangilder                        2.0  0  0  0  0  0  19  13  0.57
Ehmke                            1.0  3  2  2  1  1  25  15  2.70
Page             BS 1            0.1  1  0  0  0  0   8   5  0.00
Littlejohn                       0.2  0  0  0  0  0   6   3  0.00
Strelecki                        0.0  1  1  1  0  0   1   1  5.40
Settlemire       BS 1            0.1  1  0  0  0  0   7   5  0.00
Connally         L 1-1           3.0  2  1  1  4  2  64  35  2.19
Nehf                             0.0  1  0  0  0  0   1   1  5.59
                                14.1 19  7  7 10 11 271 163 
 
Crimson Tide                     INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Tyler, SA                       10.0  6  3  0  1  8 131  89  1.17
Johnson                          2.0  5  3  3  2  1  55  32  7.00
Holloway         W 2-1           3.0  2  0  0  0  0  40  23  2.35
                                15.0 13  6  3  3  9 226 144 
 
SP : Walker batted for Powell in the 8th
     Dickey batted for Vangilder in the 10th
     Dressen inserted at 3b in the 11th
     Gooch batted for Littlejohn in the 12th
     Gillis inserted at 2b in the 15th
CCT: Taitt batted for Tyler, SA in the 10th
     Washington, J batted for Hauser in the 11th
     Washington, J moved to 1b in the 12th
     Reynolds batted for Johnson in the 12th
     Fernandez batted for Cobb in the 12th
     Livingston batted for Williams,K in the 12th
     Livingston moved to lf in the 13th
     Reynolds moved to rf in the 13th
 
E-Cobb, Creacy. 2B-Blue(1), Hodapp(3), Reynolds(2). HR-Hafey(5), Hauser(4). 
RBI-Briggs(5), Blue(5), Hodapp(7), Hafey 2(19), Dressen(2), Charleston(11), 
Hauser 3(9), Washington, J(4), Reynolds(3), Livingston(5). CS-Russell, JH. 
K-Blue, Hafey 3, Thomas, C, Russell, JH, Hargreaves, Bancroft, Powell, Cobb, 
Creacy, Frisch, Hauser, Lundy 4, Spearman, Tyler, SA 2. BB-Blue, Hodapp, 
Russell, JH, Cobb, Creacy, Frisch 2, Charleston, Lundy 3, Spearman 2. 
SH-Blue, Russell, JH, Charleston. SF-Charleston. HBP-Blue. HB-Holloway. 
GWRBI: Reynolds
Temperature: 47, Sky: clear, Wind: in from center at 5 MPH.
4/22/1928, SP28-CCT28, Polo Grounds
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10 11 12
1928 Spiders           0  0  3  0  0  0  0  0  0  0  2  1
1928 Crimson Tide      0  0  1  0  0  0  2  0  0  0  2  1
 
                      13 14 15     R  H  E   LOB DP
1928 Spiders           0  0  0     6 13  0    10  0
1928 Crimson Tide      0  0  1     7 19  2    22  0
 
 
Spiders              -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Briggs            lf 1>3/fl         S.2-H        13           S/b.1-2      5         
Blue              1b   k            D.1-H        4/L          note 1     1>Johnson   
                                                                           9         
Hodapp            3b   43           D.2-H      6>63           note 2       W         
 Dressen          3b                                                                 
Hafey             cf 2>k            7            k            k            HR.1-H    
Thomas, C         rf   63         4>13           3/g        9>6            k         
                                                                                     
Russell, JH       2b   W            S          7>k            3            S.B-2(e9) 
 Nehf             p                                                                  
Hargreaves        c    POCS2(136)   8            k            43           8         
                     3>e5.B-2                                                        
Bancroft          ss   k            6/L          3/fl       0>43         2>43        
Powell            p    k          5>31                                               
 Walker           ph                           8>S                                   
 Vangilder        p                                                                  
 Dickey           ph                                          7                      
 Ehmke            p                                                                  
 Page             p                                                                  
 Littlejohn       p                                                                  
 Gooch            ph                                                       S         
 Strelecki        p                                                                  
 Settlemire       p                                                                  
 Connally         p                                                                  
 Gillis           2b                                                                 
 
 1: 14/SH.2-3;1-2  2: 62.3xH;2-3;B-1 
 
 
Crimson Tide         -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Cobb              rf 1>W            k            64/f.B-1     6          8>Vangilder 
                                                                           53        
 Fernandez        ph                                                                 
 Holloway         p                                                                  
Williams,K        lf   S.1-2      3>S            43           9            8         
 Livingston       ph                                                                 
Creacy            3b   k            7          5>S          7>S            63        
                                                                                     
Frisch            2b   63.2-3;1-2   S.1-2        S.1-2        k          9>1/L       
Charleston        cf   W            4            note 1       63.1-2       8         
                                                                                     
Hauser            1b   13           S.2-H;1-3    k            HR.2-H       8         
 Washington, J    ph                                                                 
Lundy             ss 2>k            k            W            W          0>Ehmke     
                                                                           k         
Spearman          c    S          4>S            64/f         W.1-2        S         
Tyler, SA         p    54/f.B-1     k/b        6>63           k                      
 Taitt            ph                                                       6/L       
 Johnson          p                                                                  
 Reynolds         ph                                                                 
                                                                                     
 
 1: 13/SH.2-3;1-2 
 
 
Spiders              -----F------ -----G------ -----H------ -----I------ -----J------
Briggs            lf   S.1x3(95)    9                                                
Blue              1b   W.1-2        HBP                                              
                                                                                     
Hodapp            3b                                                                 
 Dressen          3b   note 1       9                                                
Hafey             cf   9          5>53                                               
Thomas, C         rf 3>Holloway     7                                                
                       S                                                             
Russell, JH       2b   14/SH.1-2    S                                                
 Nehf             p                                                                  
Hargreaves        c    63           13                                               
                                                                                     
Bancroft          ss   63                                                            
Powell            p                                                                  
 Walker           ph                                                                 
 Vangilder        p                                                                  
 Dickey           ph                                                                 
 Ehmke            p                                                                  
 Page             p                                                                  
 Littlejohn       p                                                                  
 Gooch            ph                                                                 
 Strelecki        p                                                                  
 Settlemire       p                                                                  
 Connally         p  4>4                                                             
 Gillis           2b                                                                 
 
 1: S.2-H;1-3;B-2 
 
 
Crimson Tide         -----F------ -----G------ -----H------ -----I------ -----J------
Cobb              rf   64/f         Settlemire                                       
                                                                                     
 Fernandez        ph                63                                               
 Holloway         p                              64/f                                
Williams,K        lf 1>S                                                             
 Livingston       ph                S.2-H;B-2  4>6                                   
Creacy            3b   S.1-2        Connally     53                                  
                                    IW                                               
Frisch            2b   W.2-3;1-2    W.2-3;1-2    9                                   
Charleston        cf   Page         note 1     5>8                                   
                       note 2                                                        
Hauser            1b                                                                 
 Washington, J    ph   S.3-H;1-2    9            S                                   
Lundy             ss   Littlejohn 3>k            W.1-2                               
                       13.2-3;1-2                                                    
Spearman          c    43           k            W.2-3;1-2                           
Tyler, SA         p                                                                  
 Taitt            ph                                                                 
 Johnson          p  2>Strelecki                                                     
 Reynolds         ph   D            S            Nehf                                
                                                 note 3                              
 
 1: 32/f.2-3;1-2;B-1  2: 8/SF.3-H;2-3  3: S.3-H;2-3;1-2 
 
 
Spiders          IN OUT ER                  Crimson Tide     IN OUT ER                  
Powell           A1  D9  3                  Tyler, SA        A1  E1  0                  
Vangilder        E1  E6  0                  Johnson          E2  F4  3                  
Ehmke            E7  F4  2                  Holloway         F5  G7  0 W 2-1            
Page             F5  F6  0 BS 1                                                         
Littlejohn       F7  F8  0                                                              
Strelecki        F9  F9  1                                                              
Settlemire       G1  G2  0 BS 1                                                         
Connally         G3  H8  1 L 1-1                                                        
Nehf             H9  H9  0                                                              
4/22/1928, SP28-CCT28, Polo Grounds
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10 11 12
1928 Spiders           0  0  3  0  0  0  0  0  0  0  2  1
1928 Crimson Tide      0  0  1  0  0  0  2  0  0  0  2  1
 
                      13 14 15     R  H  E   LOB DP
1928 Spiders           0  0  0     6 13  0    10  0
1928 Crimson Tide      0  0  1     7 19  2    22  0
 
Score O Rnr BS  Event
----- - --- --  -----
 
**************  Top of the 1st inning, Spiders batting
 0-0  0 --- 10  Briggs popped out to first (BX)
 0-0  1 --- 22  Blue struck out (BCCBFFS)
 0-0  2 --- 21  Hodapp grounded out to second (BCBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 1st inning, Crimson Tide batting
 0-0  0 --- 31  Cobb walked (BCBBB)
 0-0  0 1-- 12  Williams,K lined a single to center, Cobb to second 
                  (11CFBX)
 0-0  0 12- 12  Creacy struck out (BSSFS)
 0-0  1 12- 01  Frisch grounded out to short, Cobb to third, Williams,K 
                  to second (FX)
 0-0  2 -23 31  Charleston walked (BBSBB)
 0-0  2 123 30  Hauser grounded out to the mound (BBBX)
 
**************  Top of the 2nd inning, Spiders batting
 0-0  0 --- 12  Hafey struck out (SFBS)
 0-0  1 --- 10  Thomas, C grounded out to short (BX)
 0-0  2 --- 32  Russell, JH walked (CBFBBFB)
 0-0  2 1-- 32  Russell, JH was caught stealing second after being picked 
                  off first by Tyler, SA (BCBFB>F11)
 
**************  Bottom of the 2nd inning, Crimson Tide batting
 0-0  0 --- 32  Lundy struck out (BCBBSS)
 0-0  1 --- 00  Spearman lined a single down the right field line (X)
 0-0  1 1-- 22  Tyler, SA grounded to third, forcing Spearman at second, 
                  Tyler, SA to first (CSbBBX)
 0-0  2 1-- 02  Cobb struck out (FFS)
 
**************  Top of the 3rd inning, Spiders batting
 0-0  0 --- 02  Hargreaves to second on an error by the third baseman 
                  Creacy (CFX)
 0-0  0 -2- 22  Bancroft struck out (BbCSBFS)
 0-0  1 -2- 02  Powell struck out (CSC)
 0-0  2 -2- 21  Briggs lined a single down the right field line, 
                  Hargreaves scored (BBCX)
 1-0  2 1-- 31  Blue grounded a double down the first base line, Briggs 
                  scored (BBCBX)
 2-0  2 -2- 00  Hodapp doubled deep to right center, Blue scored (X)
 3-0  2 -2- 21  Hafey lined out to left (FBBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 3rd inning, Crimson Tide batting
 3-0  0 --- 00  Williams,K reached on an infield single to second (X)
 3-0  0 1-- 00  Creacy flied out to left (X)
 3-0  1 1-- 11  Frisch lined a single to shallow right, Williams,K to 
                  second (FBX)
 3-0  1 12- 22  Charleston popped out to second (FCBBX)
 3-0  2 12- 21  Hauser lined a single to left center, Williams,K scored, 
                  Frisch to third (BSBX)
 3-1  2 1-3 02  Lundy struck out (CFS)
 
**************  Top of the 4th inning, Spiders batting
 3-1  0 --- 01  Thomas, C grounded out to the mound (SX)
 3-1  1 --- 02  Russell, JH reached on an infield single to short (SFX)
 3-1  1 1-- 00  Hargreaves flied out to center (>X)
 3-1  2 1-- 00  Bancroft lined out to short (1X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 4th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 3-1  0 --- 11  Spearman lined a single to left (BFX)
 3-1  0 1-- 02  Tyler, SA struck out on a fouled bunt (CFFb)
 3-1  1 1-- 11  Cobb grounded to short, forcing Spearman at second, Cobb 
                  to first (CBX)
 3-1  2 1-- 32  Williams,K grounded out to second (BBSFB>F>F>X)
 
**************  Top of the 5th inning, Spiders batting
 3-1  0 --- 00  Powell grounded out to first (X)
 3-1  1 --- 02  Briggs grounded out to the mound (SFX)
 3-1  2 --- 12  Blue lined out to second (FCBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 5th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 3-1  0 --- 12  Creacy grounded a single up the middle (BSFFX)
 3-1  0 1-- 32  Frisch lined a single up the middle, Creacy to second 
                  (BBFCFBX)
 3-1  0 12- 00  Charleston sacrifice bunted to the mound, Creacy to 
                  third, Frisch to second (Xb)
 3-1  1 -23 32  Hauser struck out (FFBBFBS)
 3-1  2 -23 31  Lundy walked (BBBCB)
 3-1  2 123 20  Spearman grounded to short, forcing Lundy at second (BBX)
 
**************  Top of the 6th inning, Spiders batting
 3-1  0 --- 21  Hodapp grounded out to short (BBCX)
 3-1  1 --- 02  Hafey struck out (CCC)
 3-1  2 --- 12  Thomas, C grounded out to first (BFFFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 6th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 3-1  0 --- 10  Tyler, SA grounded out to short (BX)
 3-1  1 --- 21  Cobb popped out to short (BCBX)
 3-1  2 --- 11  Williams,K popped out to right (CBX)
 
**************  Top of the 7th inning, Spiders batting
 3-1  0 --- 12  Russell, JH struck out (CFBS)
 3-1  1 --- 02  Hargreaves struck out (CCFC)
 3-1  2 --- 21  Bancroft popped out to first (BFBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 7th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 3-1  0 --- 01  Creacy grounded a single between third and short (CX)
 3-1  0 1-- 02  Frisch struck out (FFFFFS)
 3-1  1 1-- 12  Charleston grounded out to short, Creacy to second (CFBX)
 3-1  2 -2- 01  Hauser homered deep down the right field line, Creacy 
                  scored (SX)
 3-3  2 --- 30  Lundy walked (BBBB)
 3-3  2 1-- 32  Spearman walked, Lundy to second (BSBBF>B)
 3-3  2 12- 12  Tyler, SA struck out (BSCFS)
 
**************  Top of the 8th inning, Spiders batting
                Walker pinch hitting for Powell
 3-3  0 --- 11  Walker grounded a single between first and second (BFX)
 3-3  0 1-- 00  Briggs bunted for a single, Walker to second (Xb)
 3-3  0 12- 00  Blue sacrifice bunted to the mound, Walker to third, 
                  Briggs to second (Xb)
 3-3  1 -23 11  Hodapp grounded to short, Walker out at home, Briggs to 
                  third, Hodapp to first (CBX)
 3-3  2 1-3 22  Hafey struck out (FSBBS)
 
**************  Bottom of the 8th inning, Crimson Tide batting
                Vangilder now pitching
 3-3  0 --- 11  Cobb grounded out to third (BFX)
 3-3  1 --- 21  Williams,K flied out to center (BBFX)
 3-3  2 --- 12  Creacy grounded out to short (CBFX)
 
**************  Top of the 9th inning, Spiders batting
 3-3  0 --- 10  Thomas, C popped out to short (BX)
 3-3  1 --- 31  Russell, JH popped out to first (CBBBX)
 3-3  2 --- 32  Hargreaves grounded out to second (BBBCFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 9th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 3-3  0 --- 00  Frisch lined out to the mound (X)
 3-3  1 --- 01  Charleston flied out to center (CX)
 3-3  2 --- 22  Hauser flied out to center (CBFBX)
 
**************  Top of the 10th inning, Spiders batting
 3-3  0 --- 02  Bancroft grounded out to second (CFX)
                Dickey pinch hitting for Vangilder
 3-3  1 --- 11  Dickey flied out to left (BSX)
 3-3  2 --- 01  Briggs popped out to third (CX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 10th inning, Crimson Tide batting
                Ehmke now pitching
 3-3  0 --- 02  Lundy struck out (CSS)
 3-3  1 --- 10  Spearman lined a single to right (BX)
                Taitt pinch hitting for Tyler, SA
 3-3  1 1-- 10  Taitt lined out to short (BX)
 3-3  2 1-- 20  Cobb grounded to short, forcing Spearman at second (BBX)
 
**************  Top of the 11th inning, Spiders batting
                Johnson now pitching
 3-3  0 --- 11  Blue lined out to right (BCX)
 3-3  1 --- 32  Hodapp walked (BFBBFB)
 3-3  1 1-- 32  Hafey homered deep down the left-field line, Hodapp 
                  scored (1CFFBBBX)
 5-3  1 --- 22  Thomas, C struck out (CBBFC)
 5-3  2 --- 01  Russell, JH lined a single to shallow right, Russell, JH 
                  to second on an error by the right fielder Cobb (FX)
 5-3  2 -2- 32  Hargreaves flied out to center (BBFBFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 11th inning, Crimson Tide batting
                Dressen now playing third base
 5-3  0 --- 22  Williams,K lined a single between third and short (CFBFBX)
 5-3  0 1-- 00  Creacy lined a single to shallow center, Williams,K to 
                  second (X)
 5-3  0 12- 32  Frisch walked, Williams,K to third, Creacy to second 
                  (FbBCBBFFB)
                Page now pitching
 5-3  0 123 10  Charleston hit a sacrifice fly to center, Williams,K 
                  scored, Creacy to third (BX)
                Washington, J pinch hitting for Hauser
 5-4  1 1-3 22  Washington, J reached on an infield single to third, 
                  Creacy scored, Frisch to second (CFBBFX)
                Littlejohn now pitching
 5-5  1 12- 10  Lundy grounded out to the mound, Frisch to third, 
                  Washington, J to second (BX)
 5-5  2 -23 21  Spearman grounded out to second (FBBX)
 
**************  Top of the 12th inning, Spiders batting
                Washington, J moved to first base
 5-5  0 --- 32  Bancroft grounded out to second (CBBBFFFX)
                Gooch pinch hitting for Littlejohn
 5-5  1 --- 02  Gooch grounded a single between first and second (FFX)
 5-5  1 1-- 10  Briggs grounded a single between first and second, Gooch 
                  out at third (BX)
 5-5  2 1-- 32  Blue walked, Briggs to second (C1FBBFB>B)
 5-5  2 12- 10  Dressen lined a single up the middle, Briggs scored, Blue 
                  to third, Dressen to second (BX)
 6-5  2 -23 12  Hafey flied out to right (CBFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 12th inning, Crimson Tide batting
                Strelecki now pitching
                Reynolds pinch hitting for Johnson
 6-5  0 --- 00  Reynolds grounded a double down the third base line (X)
                Settlemire now pitching
                Fernandez pinch hitting for Cobb
 6-5  0 -2- 02  Fernandez grounded out to short (CbFX)
                Livingston pinch hitting for Williams,K
 6-5  1 -2- 21  Livingston grounded a single between first and second, 
                  Reynolds scored, Livingston to second (BBCX)
                Connally now pitching
 6-6  1 -2- 30  Creacy was walked intentionally (IIII)
 6-6  1 12- 31  Frisch walked, Livingston to third, Creacy to second 
                  (BCBBB)
 6-6  1 123 31  Charleston grounded to first, forcing Livingston at home, 
                  Creacy to third, Frisch to second, Charleston to first 
                  (BBBCX)
 6-6  2 123 22  Washington, J popped out to right (BCBFFX)
 
**************  Top of the 13th inning, Spiders batting
                Holloway now pitching
                Livingston moved to left field
                Reynolds moved to right field
 6-6  0 --- 12  Thomas, C lined a single to shallow left (CCBX)
 6-6  0 1-- 10  Russell, JH sacrifice bunted to the mound, Thomas, C to 
                  second (111BbXb)
 6-6  1 -2- 01  Hargreaves grounded out to short (CX)
 6-6  2 -2- 12  Bancroft grounded out to short (BFFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 13th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 6-6  0 --- 12  Lundy struck out (BFFS)
 6-6  1 --- 12  Spearman struck out (CBFS)
 6-6  2 --- 01  Reynolds grounded a single between third and short (CX)
 6-6  2 1-- 12  Holloway grounded to short, forcing Reynolds at second 
                  (CBSX)
 
**************  Top of the 14th inning, Spiders batting
 6-6  0 --- 12  Connally popped out to second (CBCX)
 6-6  1 --- 20  Briggs flied out to right (BBX)
 6-6  2 --- 30  Blue was hit by a pitch (BBBH)
 6-6  2 1-- 32  Dressen flied out to right (CSBBB>X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 14th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 6-6  0 --- 12  Livingston popped out to short (BFSX)
 6-6  1 --- 21  Creacy grounded out to third (BBCX)
 6-6  2 --- 11  Frisch flied out to right (CBX)
 
**************  Top of the 15th inning, Spiders batting
 6-6  0 --- 10  Hafey grounded out to third (BX)
 6-6  1 --- 12  Thomas, C flied out to left (BCFX)
 6-6  2 --- 21  Russell, JH grounded a single up the middle (BSBX)
 6-6  2 1-- 00  Hargreaves grounded out to the mound (X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 15th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 6-6  0 --- 12  Charleston flied out to center (FCFBFFX)
 6-6  1 --- 00  Washington, J grounded a single between third and short 
                  (X)
 6-6  1 1-- 31  Lundy walked, Washington, J to second (BBBCB)
 6-6  1 12- 32  Spearman walked, Washington, J to third, Lundy to second 
                  (BCBCBB)
                Gillis now playing second base
                Nehf now pitching
 6-6  1 123 00  Reynolds lined a single between first and second, 
                  Washington, J scored, Lundy to third, Spearman to 
                  second (X)