4/12/1928, PC28-CCT28, Polo Grounds
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9     R  H  E   LOB DP
1928 Caterpillars      1  0  0  0  3  0  0  0  0     4 10  4     6  0
1928 Crimson Tide      2  0  0  0  1  0  0  3  x     6 12  2    10  1
 
Caterpillars         AB  R  H BI   AVG    Crimson Tide         AB  R  H BI   AVG
Duncan F.L.       c   4  2  2  2  .429    Reynolds          rf  5  2  3  1  .300
 Myer             ph  1  0  0  0  .200    Livingston        lf  3  1  1  1  .143
Lind              2b  4  0  1  0  .286     Spearman         ph  1  0  1  1  .444
Richbourg         rf  3  0  0  1  .214     Holloway         p   0  0  0  0  .000
Herman            lf  4  0  2  1  .389    Creacy            3b  5  1  2  2  .185
Morgan            1b  4  0  1  0  .111    Washington, J     1b  5  0  1  0  .333
 Strong           p   0  0  0  0  .000    Charleston        cf  3  0  1  0  .292
Bartell           ss  4  0  1  0  .091    Frisch            2b  4  0  0  0  .375
Allen             cf  4  0  1  0  .333    Lundy             ss  4  1  1  0  .333
Johnson, Ju       3b  3  1  1  0  .167    Fernandez         c   4  0  0  0  .250
 Dorman           ph  1  0  0  0  .250    Hoyt              p   3  0  1  0  .200
Foster, W         p   3  1  1  0  .200     Kelly            ph  1  1  1  0 1.000
 Grimm            1b  1  0  0  0  .250                         38  6 12  5
                     36  4 10  4
 
Caterpillars                     INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Foster, W        L 0-1           7.1 12  6  6  2  5 125  77  4.11
Strong                           0.2  0  0  0  0  0   8   5  0.00
                                 8.0 12  6  6  2  5 133  82 
 
Crimson Tide                     INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Hoyt             W 1-0           8.0  9  4  1  0  0  88  64  1.93
Holloway         S 1             1.0  1  0  0  0  0  18  12  0.00
                                 9.0 10  4  1  0  0 106  76 
 
PC : Grimm inserted at 1b in the 8th
     Dorman batted for Johnson, Ju in the 9th
     Myer batted for Duncan F.L. in the 9th
CCT: Kelly batted for Hoyt in the 8th
     Spearman batted for Livingston in the 8th
     Kelly moved to lf in the 9th
 
E-Bartell 3, Allen, Creacy, Washington, J. 2B-Reynolds(1), Spearman(2). 
3B-Charleston(1). HR-Duncan F.L.(1), Livingston(1), Creacy(1). 
RBI-Duncan F.L. 2(2), Richbourg(4), Herman(3), Reynolds(2), Livingston(1), 
Creacy 2(3), Spearman(3). K-Washington, J, Charleston, Frisch, Lundy, 
Fernandez. BB-Livingston, Charleston. SF-Richbourg. 
Temperature: 51, Sky: cloudy, Wind: left to right at 11 MPH.
4/12/1928, PC28-CCT28, Polo Grounds
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9     R  H  E   LOB DP
1928 Caterpillars      1  0  0  0  3  0  0  0  0     4 10  4     6  0
1928 Crimson Tide      2  0  0  0  1  0  0  3  x     6 12  2    10  1
 
 
Caterpillars         -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Duncan F.L.       c  1>HR           43           S.3-H;1-2    43                     
 Myer             ph                                                       7         
Lind              2b   7            43           S.2-3;1-2    63                     
Richbourg         rf   8          4>5/fl         note 1     8>9                      
Herman            lf   8            S            S.3-H;1-2    43                     
Morgan            1b 2>S            9            64/f         9                      
 Strong           p                                                                  
Bartell           ss   643/gdp      6          6>31         9>Holloway               
                                                              S                      
Allen             cf   S          5>31           43           64/f.B-1               
Johnson, Ju       3b   53           S            63                                  
 Dorman           ph                                          e3.1-2;B-1             
Foster, W         p  3>63           e5/fl      7>31                                  
                                    S.1-3                                            
 Grimm            1b                                          7                      
 
 1: 7/SF.3-H;2-3 
 
 
Crimson Tide         -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Reynolds          rf 1>D          3>9            31           S.1-3        note 1    
Livingston        lf   23.2-3       W          5>HR           6/L                    
 Spearman         ph                                                       D.3-H     
 Holloway         p                                                                  
Creacy            3b   HR.3-H       e6.1-2;B-1   7          7>S            Strong    
                                                                           63        
Washington, J     1b   S            k            6            note 2       8         
Charleston        cf   k            W.2-3;1-2    T            9                      
Frisch            2b   k            64/f         3/g          63                     
Lundy             ss 2>k          4>8          6>43         8>S                      
Fernandez         c    k            e6.B-2       3/g          2/fl                   
Hoyt              p    7            31.2-3       S                                   
 Kelly            ph                                          S.1-2                  
 
 1: S.2-H;1-H(e8/th);B-3  2: 46/f.B-2(e6/th) 
 
 
Caterpillars     IN OUT ER                  Crimson Tide     IN OUT ER                  
Foster, W        A1  E2  6 L 0-1            Hoyt             A1  D5  1 W 1-0            
Strong           E3  E4  0                  Holloway         D6  E1  0 S 1              
4/12/1928, PC28-CCT28, Polo Grounds
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9     R  H  E   LOB DP
1928 Caterpillars      1  0  0  0  3  0  0  0  0     4 10  4     6  0
1928 Crimson Tide      2  0  0  0  1  0  0  3  x     6 12  2    10  1
 
Score O Rnr BS  Event
----- - --- --  -----
 
**************  Top of the 1st inning, Caterpillars batting
 0-0  0 --- 10  Duncan F.L. homered deep down the left-field line (BX)
 1-0  0 --- 00  Lind flied out to left (X)
 1-0  1 --- 00  Richbourg flied out to center (X)
 1-0  2 --- 00  Herman flied out to center (X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 1st inning, Crimson Tide batting
 1-0  0 --- 12  Reynolds doubled deep to right (BFCX)
 1-0  0 -2- 21  Livingston grounded out to the catcher, Reynolds to third 
                  (BCBX)
 1-0  1 --3 10  Creacy homered deep down the left-field line, Reynolds 
                  scored (BX)
 1-2  1 --- 00  Washington, J lined a single to right center (X)
 1-2  1 1-- 32  Charleston struck out (BCBFBC)
 1-2  2 1-- 32  Frisch struck out (FCBBB>S)
 
**************  Top of the 2nd inning, Caterpillars batting
 1-2  0 --- 01  Morgan lined a single to shallow left (CX)
 1-2  0 1-- 00  Bartell grounded into a double play, Lundy to Frisch to 
                  Washington, J (1X)
 1-2  2 --- 00  Allen reached on an infield single to first (X)
 1-2  2 1-- 32  Johnson, Ju grounded out to third (BCBBF>X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 2nd inning, Crimson Tide batting
 1-2  0 --- 32  Lundy struck out (BBCBCS)
 1-2  1 --- 12  Fernandez struck out (CCFBS)
 1-2  2 --- 00  Hoyt flied out to left (X)
 
**************  Top of the 3rd inning, Caterpillars batting
 1-2  0 --- 01  Foster, W grounded out to short (FX)
 1-2  1 --- 10  Duncan F.L. grounded out to second (BX)
 1-2  2 --- 32  Lind grounded out to second (BBBCFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 3rd inning, Crimson Tide batting
 1-2  0 --- 20  Reynolds lined out to right (BBX)
 1-2  1 --- 32  Livingston walked (BCFBBFB)
 1-2  1 1-- 10  Livingston to second, Creacy to first on an error by the 
                  shortstop Bartell (BX)
 1-2  1 12- 32  Washington, J struck out (BCFBBS)
 1-2  2 12- 31  Charleston walked, Livingston to third, Creacy to second 
                  (BBCBB)
 1-2  2 123 02  Frisch grounded to short, forcing Charleston at second 
                  (CCX)
 
**************  Top of the 4th inning, Caterpillars batting
 1-2  0 --- 22  Richbourg popped out to third (CBBFFX)
 1-2  1 --- 22  Herman lined a single to shallow center (FBBFX)
 1-2  1 1-- 01  Morgan flied out to right (CX)
 1-2  2 1-- 21  Bartell popped out to short (BCBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 4th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 1-2  0 --- 31  Lundy flied out to center (BBBSX)
 1-2  1 --- 12  Fernandez to second on an error by the shortstop Bartell 
                  (BFSX)
 1-2  1 -2- 02  Hoyt grounded out to first, Fernandez to third (SFX)
 1-2  2 --3 11  Reynolds grounded out to first (BCX)
 
**************  Top of the 5th inning, Caterpillars batting
 1-2  0 --- 21  Allen grounded out to first (FBBX)
 1-2  1 --- 11  Johnson, Ju grounded a single to left (BCX)
 1-2  1 1-- 00  Foster, W continues to bat after the third baseman Creacy 
                  dropped a foul popup for an error (XF)
 1-2  1 1-- 02  Foster, W grounded a single between first and second, 
                  Johnson, Ju to third (XF.FbFX)
 1-2  1 1-3 00  Duncan F.L. grounded a single up the middle, Johnson, Ju 
                  scored, Foster, W to second (X)
 2-2  1 12- 10  Lind lined a single to shallow left, Foster, W to third, 
                  Duncan F.L. to second (BX)
 2-2  1 123 11  Richbourg hit a sacrifice fly to left, Foster, W scored, 
                  Duncan F.L. to third (FBX)
 3-2  2 1-3 00  Herman reached on an infield single to the pitcher, 
                  Duncan F.L. scored, Lind to second (X)
 4-2  2 12- 00  Morgan grounded to short, forcing Herman at second (X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 5th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 4-2  0 --- 11  Livingston homered deep to left (FBX)
 4-3  0 --- 00  Creacy lined out to left (X)
 4-3  1 --- 01  Washington, J popped out to short (CX)
 4-3  2 --- 22  Charleston tripled deep to left center (BBSSX)
 4-3  2 --3 00  Frisch grounded out to first (X)
 
**************  Top of the 6th inning, Caterpillars batting
 4-3  0 --- 01  Bartell grounded out to first (CX)
 4-3  1 --- 01  Allen grounded out to second (CX)
 4-3  2 --- 11  Johnson, Ju grounded out to short (FBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 6th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 4-3  0 --- 10  Lundy grounded out to second (BX)
 4-3  1 --- 01  Fernandez grounded out to first (CX)
 4-3  2 --- 00  Hoyt reached on an infield single to second (X)
 4-3  2 1-- 00  Reynolds singled down the left field line, Hoyt to third 
                  (X)
 4-3  2 1-3 21  Livingston lined out to short (BFBX)
 
**************  Top of the 7th inning, Caterpillars batting
 4-3  0 --- 12  Foster, W grounded out to first (FBFX)
 4-3  1 --- 01  Duncan F.L. grounded out to second (SX)
 4-3  2 --- 01  Lind grounded out to short (CX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 7th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 4-3  0 --- 11  Creacy grounded a single up the middle (CBX)
 4-3  0 1-- 01  Washington, J grounded to second, forcing Creacy at 
                  second, Washington, J to second on an error by the 
                  shortstop Bartell (SX)
 4-3  1 -2- 12  Charleston flied out to right (CBSX)
 4-3  2 -2- 00  Frisch grounded out to short (X)
 
**************  Top of the 8th inning, Caterpillars batting
 4-3  0 --- 01  Richbourg flied out to right (CX)
 4-3  1 --- 11  Herman grounded out to second (FBX)
 4-3  2 --- 22  Morgan flied out to right (BBFFFX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 8th inning, Crimson Tide batting
 4-3  0 --- 01  Lundy lined a single to shallow left (CX)
 4-3  0 1-- 31  Fernandez popped out to the catcher (BBCBX)
                Kelly pinch hitting for Hoyt
 4-3  1 1-- 11  Kelly grounded a single between third and short, Lundy to 
                  second (CBX)
 4-3  1 12- 22  Reynolds grounded a single up the middle, Lundy scored, 
                  Kelly scored on an error by the center fielder Allen, 
                  Reynolds to third (CBFBX)
                Spearman pinch hitting for Livingston
 4-5  1 --3 10  Spearman lined a double to right center, Reynolds scored 
                  (BX)
                Grimm now playing first base
                Strong now pitching
 4-6  1 -2- 22  Creacy grounded out to short (CSBFBX)
 4-6  2 -2- 10  Washington, J flied out to center (BX)
 
**************  Top of the 9th inning, Caterpillars batting
                Holloway now pitching
                Kelly moved to left field
 4-6  0 --- 21  Bartell lined a single down the right field line (CBBX)
 4-6  0 1-- 11  Allen grounded to short, forcing Bartell at second, Allen 
                  to first (FBX)
                Dorman pinch hitting for Johnson, Ju
 4-6  1 1-- 32  Allen to second, Dorman to first on an error by the first 
                  baseman Washington, J (CBCFBBX)
 4-6  1 12- 01  Grimm flied out to left (>FX)
                Myer pinch hitting for Duncan F.L.
 4-6  2 12- 01  Myer flied out to left (FX)