5/21/1923, CG23-WW23, Forbes Field
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10 11 12
1923 Giants            0  0  3  0  0  1  3  0  0  0  0  0
1923 Warbirds          0  0  0  0  3  4  0  0  0  0  0  0
 
                      13     R  H  E   LOB DP
1923 Giants            0     7 11  3     8  2
1923 Warbirds          1     8 16  2    14  0
 
Giants               AB  R  H BI   AVG    Warbirds             AB  R  H BI   AVG
Goslin            lf  4  2  2  0  .292    Judge             1b  6  2  2  0  .312
Traynor           3b  6  2  3  1  .300    Veach             rf  6  3  2  1  .281
Hawkins           1b  6  2  1  1  .211    Hargrave,B        c   6  1  3  2  .348
Gardner, J        cf  6  0  1  1  .250    Harris,J          lf  6  0  1  1  .339
Briggs            rf  3  0  0  0  .222    Russell, JH       2b  7  0  3  4  .223
 Stuart           p   0  0  0  0  .000    Mostil            cf  6  0  1  0  .284
 Shaute           p   0  0  0  0  .111    Bohne             3b  6  0  0  0  .225
 Meeker           p   0  0  0  0  .000    Maranville        ss  5  1  2  0  .255
 Gearin           p   0  0  0  0  .333    Rogan             p   3  1  2  0  .344
 Dreke            ph  1  0  0  0  .230     Quinn            p   1  0  0  0  .333
 Marberry         p   2  0  0  0  .200     Grigsby          ph  1  0  0  0  .176
 Zachary          p   0  0  0  0  .053     McQuaid          p   0  0  0  0  .000
High              2b  5  0  1  2  .275     Mason            ph  1  0  0  0  .308
Galloway          ss  6  0  2  0  .203     Pfeffer          p   0  0  0  0  .000
Duncan F.L.       c   2  1  1  1  .221                         54  8 16  8
 Matthews         ph  1  0  0  0  .000
 Brown, J         c   2  0  0  0  .240
Dickerman         p   2  0  0  0  .125
 Welch            rf  4  0  0  0  .211
                     50  7 11  6
 
Giants                           INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Dickerman                        4.2  7  3  3  0  0  57  38  7.31
Stuart                           0.1  1  0  0  0  0  11   7  6.00
Shaute           H 1             0.1  1  3  3  2  0  15   6  7.03
Meeker           BS 1            0.0  3  1  1  0  0  13   8  5.19
Gearin                           0.2  0  0  0  0  2  10   8  6.32
Marberry         L 0-1           6.0  2  1  0  1  4  78  45  2.87
Zachary                          0.1  2  0  0  1  0  14   6  7.85
                                12.1 16  8  7  4  6 198 118 
 
Warbirds                         INN  H  R ER BB  K PCH STR   ERA
Rogan                            6.0  8  7  6  3  5 118  73  2.78
Quinn            BS 4            3.0  2  0  0  0  1  38  27  4.56
McQuaid                          3.0  1  0  0  0  0  30  21  4.98
Pfeffer          W 1-1           1.0  0  0  0  0  3  21  14  5.66
                                13.0 11  7  6  3  9 207 135 
 
CG : Welch inserted at rf in the 5th
     Dreke batted for Gearin in the 7th
     Matthews batted for Duncan F.L. in the 8th
     Brown, J inserted at c in the 8th
WW : Grigsby batted for Quinn in the 9th
     Mason batted for McQuaid in the 12th
 
E-Traynor, High, Galloway, Bohne 2. 2B-Hargrave,B(5). 3B-Traynor(4). 
HR-Duncan F.L.(2). RBI-Traynor(13), Hawkins(7), Gardner, J(13), High 2(10), 
Duncan F.L.(11), Veach(13), Hargrave,B 2(38), Harris,J(45), 
Russell, JH 4(14). CS-Galloway. K-Goslin, Gardner, J, Briggs, Galloway 3, 
Dickerman, Welch, Brown, J, Mostil 2, Bohne 2, Maranville, Grigsby. 
BB-Goslin 2, Duncan F.L., Judge, Veach, Harris,J, Maranville. SF-High. 
HBP-Hargrave,B. HB-Dickerman. WP-Zachary. 
GWRBI: Russell, JH
Temperature: 76, Sky: clear, Wind: right to left at 1 MPH.
5/21/1923, CG23-WW23, Forbes Field
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10 11 12
1923 Giants            0  0  3  0  0  1  3  0  0  0  0  0
1923 Warbirds          0  0  0  0  3  4  0  0  0  0  0  0
 
                      13     R  H  E   LOB DP
1923 Giants            0     7 11  3     8  2
1923 Warbirds          1     8 16  2    14  0
 
 
Giants               -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Goslin            lf 1>k          3>W            S          7>W            S         
Traynor           3b   e5.B-2       T.1-H        53           S.1-2        7         
Hawkins           1b   9            e5.3-H;B-1 5>9            S.2-H;1-3  9>9         
Gardner, J        cf   k            63.1-2       7            Quinn        43        
                                                              S.3-H;1-2              
Briggs            rf 2>k            8            3/g                                 
 Stuart           p                                                                  
 Shaute           p                                                                  
 Meeker           p                                                                  
 Gearin           p                                                                  
 Dreke            ph                                          note 1                 
 Marberry         p                                                        8         
 Zachary          p                                                                  
High              2b   7            S.2-H      6>53           9/SF.3-H   0>McQuaid   
                                                                           5         
Galloway          ss   S            k            S            k            8         
                                                                                     
Duncan F.L.       c    W.1-2      4>5            CS2(24)                             
                                                 HR                                  
 Matthews         ph                                        8>13                     
 Brown, J         c                                                        43        
Dickerman         p    k            13                                               
 Welch            rf                             7            3/g        1>7         
 
 1: 64/f.2-3;B-1 
 
 
Warbirds             -----A------ -----B------ -----C------ -----D------ -----E------
Judge             1b 1>S            S            note 1       W.1-2        9         
Veach             rf   363/gdp      4/f.B-1      S.3-H;1-3    W.2-3;1-2  8>7         
                                                                                     
Hargrave,B        c    e5.B-1       S.1-2        HBP.1-2      Meeker       S         
                                                              note 2                 
Harris,J          lf   e4.1-2;B-1   8            5/fl         S.3-H;2-3    8         
                                                                                     
Russell, JH       2b   6          4>53           note 3       S.3-H;1-2    43        
Mostil            cf 2>63           13           Stuart       Gearin     9>9         
                                                 S.2-3;1-2    k                      
Bohne             3b   5/fl         53           43           k            k         
Maranville        ss   3/g        5>S          6>Shaute     7>Marberry     W         
                                                 43           S                      
Rogan             p  3>53           S.1-2        S                                   
 Quinn            p                                           note 4                 
 Grigsby          ph                                                       k         
 McQuaid          p                                                                  
 Mason            ph                                                                 
 Pfeffer          p                                                                  
 
 1: 64/f.2-3;B-1  2: D.3-H;2-H;1-3  3: S.3-H;2-H;1-2  4: 5/dp.1x1(53) 
 
 
Giants               -----F------ -----G------ -----H------ -----I------ -----J------
Goslin            lf   9                                                             
Traynor           3b   S                                                             
Hawkins           1b   63                                                            
Gardner, J        cf 2>5/fl                                                          
                                                                                     
Briggs            rf                                                                 
 Stuart           p                                                                  
 Shaute           p                                                                  
 Meeker           p                                                                  
 Gearin           p                                                                  
 Dreke            ph                                                                 
 Marberry         p    63                                                            
 Zachary          p                                                                  
High              2b   7                                                             
                                                                                     
Galloway          ss 3>Pfeffer                                                       
                       k                                                             
Duncan F.L.       c                                                                  
                                                                                     
 Matthews         ph                                                                 
 Brown, J         c    k                                                             
Dickerman         p                                                                  
 Welch            rf   k                                                             
 
 
Warbirds             -----F------ -----G------ -----H------ -----I------ -----J------
Judge             1b 0>43         3>e6.B-1                                           
Veach             rf   53           Zachary                                          
                                    S.1-2                                            
Hargrave,B        c    63           note 1                                           
                                                                                     
Harris,J          lf 1>3/g          wp.2-3;1-2                                       
                                    IW                                               
Russell, JH       2b   9            note 2                                           
Mostil            cf   k                                                             
                                                                                     
Bohne             3b 2>43                                                            
Maranville        ss   k                                                             
                                                                                     
Rogan             p                                                                  
 Quinn            p                                                                  
 Grigsby          ph                                                                 
 McQuaid          p                                                                  
 Mason            ph   8                                                             
 Pfeffer          p                                                                  
 
 1: 5/f.1-2;B-1  2: S.3-H;2-3;1-2 
 
 
Giants           IN OUT ER                  Warbirds         IN OUT ER                  
Dickerman        A1  C5  3                  Rogan            A1  D3  6                  
Stuart           C6  C7  0                  Quinn            D4  E5  0 BS 4             
Shaute           C8  D2  3 H 1              McQuaid          E6  F6  0                  
Meeker           D3  D5  1 BS 1             Pfeffer          F7  F9  0 W 1-1            
Gearin           D6  D7  0                                                              
Marberry         D8  G1  0 L 0-1                                                        
Zachary          G2  G5  0                                                              
5/21/1923, CG23-WW23, Forbes Field
 
                       1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9 10 11 12
1923 Giants            0  0  3  0  0  1  3  0  0  0  0  0
1923 Warbirds          0  0  0  0  3  4  0  0  0  0  0  0
 
                      13     R  H  E   LOB DP
1923 Giants            0     7 11  3     8  2
1923 Warbirds          1     8 16  2    14  0
 
Score O Rnr BS  Event
----- - --- --  -----
 
**************  Top of the 1st inning, Giants batting
 0-0  0 --- 12  Goslin struck out (BSFS)
 0-0  1 --- 22  Traynor to second on an error by the third baseman Bohne 
                  (CSBBX)
 0-0  1 -2- 22  Hawkins flied out to right (FFBBX)
 0-0  2 -2- 22  Gardner, J struck out (BBCSS)
 
**************  Bottom of the 1st inning, Warbirds batting
 0-0  0 --- 00  Judge grounded a single between first and second (X)
 0-0  0 1-- 02  Veach grounded into a double play, Hawkins to Galloway to 
                  Hawkins (CSX)
 0-0  2 --- 01  Hargrave,B to first on an error by the third baseman 
                  Traynor (SX)
 0-0  2 1-- 00  Hargrave,B to second, Harris,J to first on an error by 
                  the second baseman High (X)
 0-0  2 12- 10  Russell, JH popped out to short (BX)
 
**************  Top of the 2nd inning, Giants batting
 0-0  0 --- 12  Briggs struck out (CBCS)
 0-0  1 --- 22  High lined out to left (CBFBFX)
 0-0  2 --- 00  Galloway lined a single to shallow center (X)
 0-0  2 1-- 32  Duncan F.L. walked, Galloway to second (BBBCF>B)
 0-0  2 12- 02  Dickerman struck out (SCC)
 
**************  Bottom of the 2nd inning, Warbirds batting
 0-0  0 --- 00  Mostil grounded out to short (X)
 0-0  1 --- 10  Bohne popped out to third (BX)
 0-0  2 --- 01  Maranville grounded out to first (FX)
 
**************  Top of the 3rd inning, Giants batting
 0-0  0 --- 32  Goslin walked (BCBBFB)
 0-0  0 1-- 00  Traynor tripled deep to right center, Goslin scored (X)
 1-0  0 --3 12  Traynor scored, Hawkins to first on an error by the third 
                  baseman Bohne (BpSFX)
 2-0  0 1-- 12  Gardner, J grounded out to short, Hawkins to second 
                  (CBSFFFX)
 2-0  1 -2- 10  Briggs flied out to center (BX)
 2-0  2 -2- 30  High lined a single to left, Hawkins scored (BBBX)
 3-0  2 1-- 22  Galloway struck out (CBFBFFS)
 
**************  Bottom of the 3rd inning, Warbirds batting
 3-0  0 --- 11  Rogan grounded out to third (BCX)
 3-0  1 --- 22  Judge lined a single up the middle (BBFCX)
 3-0  1 1-- 02  Veach grounded to second, forcing Judge at second, Veach 
                  to first (FFX)
 3-0  2 1-- 00  Hargrave,B grounded a single up the middle, Veach to 
                  second (X)
 3-0  2 12- 11  Harris,J lined out to center (SBX)
 
**************  Top of the 4th inning, Giants batting
 3-0  0 --- 12  Duncan F.L. popped out to third (CSBX)
 3-0  1 --- 02  Dickerman grounded out to the mound (CCX)
 3-0  2 --- 00  Goslin lined a single to shallow center (X)
 3-0  2 1-- 32  Traynor grounded out to third (BBFBC>F>F>X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 4th inning, Warbirds batting
 3-0  0 --- 10  Russell, JH grounded out to third (BX)
 3-0  1 --- 10  Mostil grounded out to the mound (BX)
 3-0  2 --- 00  Bohne grounded out to third (X)
 
**************  Top of the 5th inning, Giants batting
 3-0  0 --- 22  Hawkins flied out to right (BCSBFX)
 3-0  1 --- 11  Gardner, J flied out to left (BFX)
 3-0  2 --- 12  Briggs grounded out to first (SBCX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 5th inning, Warbirds batting
 3-0  0 --- 20  Maranville lined a single down the left field line (BBX)
 3-0  0 1-- 10  Rogan grounded a single up the middle, Maranville to 
                  second (BX)
 3-0  0 12- 22  Judge grounded to short, forcing Rogan at second, 
                  Maranville to third, Judge to first (B+2BCFX)
 3-0  1 1-3 22  Veach grounded a single to left, Maranville scored, Judge 
                  to third (BSFBX)
 3-1  1 1-3 01  Hargrave,B was hit by a pitch, Veach to second (SH)
 3-1  1 123 31  Harris,J popped out to third (BCBBX)
 3-1  2 123 00  Russell, JH grounded a single between third and short, 
                  Judge scored, Veach scored, Hargrave,B to second (X)
                Welch now playing right field
                Stuart now pitching
 3-3  2 12- 22  Mostil grounded a single between third and short, 
                  Hargrave,B to third, Russell, JH to second (CBBSX)
 3-3  2 123 22  Bohne grounded out to second (FFBFBX)
 
**************  Top of the 6th inning, Giants batting
 3-3  0 --- 20  High grounded out to third (BBX)
 3-3  1 --- 00  Galloway grounded a single up the middle (X)
 3-3  1 1-- 00  Galloway was caught stealing second (>B)
 3-3  2 --- 30  Duncan F.L. homered deep to left (>B.BBX)
 4-3  2 --- 10  Welch lined out to left (BX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 6th inning, Warbirds batting
                Shaute now pitching
 4-3  0 --- 12  Maranville grounded out to second (CBFX)
 4-3  1 --- 00  Rogan grounded a single between third and short (X)
 4-3  1 1-- 31  Judge walked, Rogan to second (BBBCB)
 4-3  1 12- 31  Veach walked, Rogan to third, Judge to second (FBBBB)
                Meeker now pitching
 4-3  1 123 22  Hargrave,B lined a double to left center, Rogan scored, 
                  Judge scored, Veach to third (CFBBX)
 4-5  1 -23 10  Harris,J grounded a single up the middle, Veach scored, 
                  Hargrave,B to third (BX)
 4-6  1 1-3 22  Russell, JH grounded a single between third and short, 
                  Hargrave,B scored, Harris,J to second (SFBFBX)
                Gearin now pitching
 4-7  1 12- 12  Mostil struck out (FSFBS)
 4-7  2 12- 12  Bohne struck out (CFFBS)
 
**************  Top of the 7th inning, Giants batting
 4-7  0 --- 31  Goslin walked (BBCBB)
 4-7  0 1-- 01  Traynor lined a single to shallow left, Goslin to second 
                  (SX)
 4-7  0 12- 10  Hawkins lined a single between first and second, Goslin 
                  scored, Traynor to third (BX)
                Quinn now pitching
 5-7  0 1-3 10  Gardner, J grounded a single up the middle, Traynor 
                  scored, Hawkins to second (BX)
                Dreke pinch hitting for Gearin
 6-7  0 12- 00  Dreke grounded to short, forcing Gardner, J at second, 
                  Hawkins to third, Dreke to first (X)
 6-7  1 1-3 01  High hit a sacrifice fly to right, Hawkins scored (CX)
 7-7  2 1-- 22  Galloway struck out (FFBBS)
 
**************  Bottom of the 7th inning, Warbirds batting
                Marberry now pitching
 7-7  0 --- 11  Maranville lined a single to right center (CBX)
 7-7  0 1-- 11  Quinn hit into a double play, Traynor to Hawkins, 
                  Maranville out at first (SbBbXb)
 7-7  2 --- 02  Judge lined out to right (CFFX)
 
**************  Top of the 8th inning, Giants batting
                Matthews pinch hitting for Duncan F.L.
 7-7  0 --- 12  Matthews grounded out to the mound (SBFFFX)
 7-7  1 --- 32  Welch grounded out to first (BBBCFX)
 7-7  2 --- 00  Goslin lined a single up the middle (X)
 7-7  2 1-- 00  Traynor flied out to left (X)
 
**************  Bottom of the 8th inning, Warbirds batting
                Brown, J now playing catcher
 7-7  0 --- 12  Veach flied out to left (CBCX)
 7-7  1 --- 00  Hargrave,B lined a single between first and second (X)
 7-7  1 1-- 10  Harris,J flied out to center (BX)
 7-7  2 1-- 10  Russell, JH grounded out to second (BX)
 
**************  Top of the 9th inning, Giants batting
 7-7  0 --- 22  Hawkins flied out to right (BFBFX)
 7-7  1 --- 12  Gardner, J grounded out to second (CFBX)
 7-7  2 --- 12  Marberry flied out to center (SFFBX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 9th inning, Warbirds batting
 7-7  0 --- 31  Mostil flied out to right (BBSBX)
 7-7  1 --- 32  Bohne struck out (BBFBSS)
 7-7  2 --- 32  Maranville walked (CBBBSB)
                Grigsby pinch hitting for Quinn
 7-7  2 1-- 32  Grigsby struck out (1BSSBB>S)
 
**************  Top of the 10th inning, Giants batting
                McQuaid now pitching
 7-7  0 --- 00  High popped out to third (X)
 7-7  1 --- 02  Galloway flied out to center (CSX)
 7-7  2 --- 01  Brown, J grounded out to second (CX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 10th inning, Warbirds batting
 7-7  0 --- 31  Judge grounded out to second (BBBFX)
 7-7  1 --- 00  Veach grounded out to third (X)
 7-7  2 --- 20  Hargrave,B grounded out to short (BBX)
 
**************  Top of the 11th inning, Giants batting
 7-7  0 --- 21  Welch flied out to left (BBSX)
 7-7  1 --- 00  Goslin flied out to right (X)
 7-7  2 --- 20  Traynor grounded a single between third and short (BBX)
 7-7  2 1-- 10  Hawkins grounded out to short (BX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 11th inning, Warbirds batting
 7-7  0 --- 02  Harris,J grounded out to first (CFX)
 7-7  1 --- 10  Russell, JH popped out to right (BX)
 7-7  2 --- 22  Mostil struck out (CSBBS)
 
**************  Top of the 12th inning, Giants batting
 7-7  0 --- 32  Gardner, J popped out to third (CSFBFBBX)
 7-7  1 --- 12  Marberry grounded out to short (FSBX)
 7-7  2 --- 01  High flied out to left (CX)
 
**************  Bottom of the 12th inning, Warbirds batting
 7-7  0 --- 11  Bohne grounded out to second (BSX)
 7-7  1 --- 12  Maranville struck out (BSFS)
                Mason pinch hitting for McQuaid
 7-7  2 --- 21  Mason flied out to center (BCBX)
 
**************  Top of the 13th inning, Giants batting
                Pfeffer now pitching
 7-7  0 --- 22  Galloway struck out (FCFFBFFBS)
 7-7  1 --- 32  Brown, J struck out (FBBFBFS)
 7-7  2 --- 22  Welch struck out (CBBFS)
 
**************  Bottom of the 13th inning, Warbirds batting
 7-7  0 --- 32  Judge to first on an error by the shortstop Galloway 
                  (BCFBBX)
                Zachary now pitching
 7-7  0 1-- 00  Veach grounded a single up the middle, Judge to second (X)
 7-7  0 12- 32  Hargrave,B grounded to third, forcing Judge at third, 
                  Veach to second, Hargrave,B to first (BFBBFX)
 7-7  1 12- 11  Zachary threw a wild pitch, Veach to third, Hargrave,B to 
                  second (BFB)
 7-7  1 -23 31  Harris,J was walked intentionally (BFB.II)
 7-7  1 123 10  Russell, JH lined a single to center, Veach scored, 
                  Hargrave,B to third, Harris,J to second (BX)